Memory: Vengeance LPX 3200 2x8GB kit
CPU: Ryzen 3600
Motherboard: Gigabyte Aorus x570-i Pro Wifi
XMP disabled: system runs okay (though didn't test for extended time), memtest86 gives no errors, but obviously low performance in gaming.
XMP enabled: BSOD soon after logging into Windows 100% of the time (within the first minute), memtest86 stops because there are too many errors (10k+).
After disabling XMP again: Windows has gotten so unstable that I keep getting BSOD's (multiple tests always result in this issue). At which point I have to completely format the drive and reinstall Windows.
I read that you can manually fill in the timings in the BIOS, I have tried but honestly I'm too stupid for it. Isn't XMP supposed to fix this and pretty much work out of the box? If XMP doesn't work, can I assume something is wrong with these sticks and ask for a replacement?